S early as 1500 BC, the metal
substance called Mercury has been found in Egyptian tombs. Used in the 18th
century, mercury was an ingredient in the anti-sphilitic agents, and the
following century, the phrase "mad as a hatter" was used to describe those
sickened by mercury poisoning in the hat-making industry.
In the 1940s and 1950s, products with mercury were found to
be the cause of a disease called acrodynia, also known as pink disease.
Exposures to mercury was noted in Minamata Bay in Japan in the 1960s;
methyl-mercury treated grain in Iraq and contaminated fish in Canada in the
1969-70. A cosmetic cream from Mexico, called "Crema de Belleza-Manning," sold
in the United States in 1996 was found to have mercury.
Mercury was an essential ingredient in many medicines for
centuries, but not today. The use of fossil fuels and agricultural products
containing mercury poses a major concern about environmental pollution.
Methyl-mercury has a biological half-life of approximately 65 days.
Where else is mercury found?
This substance is found in thermometers, barometers,
batteries, blood pressure manometers, dental amalgams and antiseptic agents, in
anti-fungus medications for agricultural industry. Before 1990, mercury was also
used in paints, to prevent mildew. Today, larger fish, like Tuna (fresh or
frozen, like Albacore), Swordfish, Shark and Tilefish fishes, might contain
higher levels of methyl-mercury. For fresh water fish, bass, pike, muskellunge,
and walleye are considered to have high levels of mercury too.
Is mercury always toxic?
Mercury, in any form, is toxic. Because of its insidious
onset and non specificity in symptoms and signs, mercury poisoning is often
misdiagnosed. Mercury exposure most commonly affects the brain and nerve system,
gastrointestinal tract and kidneys.
How prevalent is mercury toxicity?
The American Association of Poison Control Centers’ Toxic
Exposure Surveillance System, in 2003, had documented 3362 exposures to mercury,
569 of them in children younger than 6 years of age, and 1705 in individuals
older than 19.
What sources are the major concerns?
The three well-publicized areas of mercury exposure concerns
include fish consumption, especially in pregnant women and children, dental
fillings or amalgams, and vaccines. According to the Public Health Service
"dental amalgams do not pose a serious health risk," and that vaccines are safe.
How about fish consumption?
Eating mercury contaminated fish is the primary source of
mercury toxicity. Since the fetal brain is more sensitive to mercury exposure,
the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) "reduced the allowable intake of
methylmercury from 0.5 mcg to 0.1 mcg of mercury per kilogram per day, which is
lower than the amount allowable according to other regulatory agencies. The Food
and Drug Administration (FDA) has "recommended that pregnant women,
breastfeeding mothers, and young children avoid eating fish with a high mercury
content (>1 ppm), such as shark, swordfish, tilefish, and king mackerel….This
also includes fresh and frozen tuna (mercury content between 0.5 ppm and 1.5 ppm)
but not canned tuna, which consists of smaller, shorter-lived species with lower
mercury levels."
In layman’s terms, what does that mean?
The recommendation translates into consumption of one can
(198 g or 7 oz) of tuna for an adult per week, and not more. For children and
women of child-bearing age, only one can per month.
What about thimerosal and autism?
Thimerosal, which contains mercury, is used as a preservative
in vaccines. There used to be fear that it caused autism in children. After
extensive studies and independent investigations, including those from other
countries, the Public Health Service agencies reported "no harmful effects have
been reported from thimerosal at doses used in vaccines," and the published
official conclusion was that "the evidence favors rejection of a causal
relationship between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism."
How do fish get contaminated with mercury?
The power plants that burn fossil fuel, particularly coal,
are the primary source of the mercury. It accumulates in streams, rivers,
oceans, and with the aid of bacteria, it is chemically transformed into
methyl-mercury, which is highly toxic. As the fish feed on aquatic organisms, it
absorbs methyl-mercury from the water. Larger fish eat smaller fish, live
longer, and so they contain higher level of methy-mercury.
Does cooking reduce the mercury?
No, cooking does not get rid of the methyl-mercury. The
US-FDA regulates commercially sold fish and seafood. The EPA monitors the
concentration of methyl-mercury in the environment and regulates industrial
releases of mercury to surface water and air. The recommendation from the
National Academy of Science states" Because of the beneficial effects of fish
consumption, the long term goal needs to be a reduction in the concentration of
mercury in fish, rather than the replacement of fish in the diet by other less
healthier food…In the interim, the best method of maintaining fish consumption
and minimizing mercury exposure is the consumption of fish known to have lower
methyl-mercury concentrations," meaning the smaller fish.
How about canned tuna?
One of the most popular fish is tuna. Canned tuna are usually
the smaller fish, rather than the larger tuna seen in the market. The
recommendation is to choose "chunk light" or "chunk" canned tuna since they
contain less mercury, compared to canned tuna labeled as "solid white" or "chunk
white," like albacore tuna, which children and pregnant or lactating mothers
should stay away from.
Which fish have low levels of mercury?
The commercially available fish/seafood considered to have lower level of
mercury besides canned "chunk light" or "chunk" tuna: catfish, cod,
flounder-sole, haddock, herring, mahi-mahi, ocean perch, rainbow trout, tilapia,
farmed trout, farmed salmon, wild salmon, sardines lobster, crab, scallops,
shrimp, and oysters.