esar Borja left
the Philippines with his family in 1976, settling in New York City. Borja,
retired from the NY Police, was one of 40,000 workers and volunteers who cleaned
up Ground Zero after the 9/11 World Trade Twin Center tragedy. The health
effects of cleaning up fumes and 1.6 million tons of pulverized debris was a
minor concern during those panic days of 9/11.
The story of this Filipino family is in the latest issue of
People magazine. The authors emphasized that the nature of such exposures to
pollution is unprecedented. There was nothing to tell all those involved what
the health effects will be.
Officer Borja spent six months working 12 to 16 hour days at
Ground Zero, first as part of the bucket brigade recovering body parts, and then
providing security.
The following summer, Officer Borja developed a persistent
cough. The cough worsened despite prescribed medications for allergies and
asthma. He died early this year from infectious pneumonia and pulmonary
fibrosis. The latter is a disease that hampers the lungs’ ability to process
oxygen. Borja smoked, but quit 10 years ago.
He left behind his wife Eva, children Nhia, Evan, and the
eldest son, Ceasar, 21, a journalism student in NY.
The devastated Ceasar is working to gain recognition and
financial compensation for Ground Zero workers. "I was fighting for my father,
but now that he’s passed away, I’ll fight for everyone else."
It’s been five years since the World Trade Center fell, but
many are still not sure of the effects of the toxic cloud. NY City’s Mt. Sinai
Medical Center has examined 19,000 of the 40,000 workers at the site. On the
first 9,442 workers studied, 70 percent had potentially permanent respiratory
problems. In all, 8,000 lawsuits alleging toxic exposure as a cause of illness
have been filed.
"That the dust is potentially fatal is pretty certain," says
Alan Fein, an NYU professor of medicine who has studied the issue.
"We cannot say with certainty whether dust is responsible for
deaths until it is proved over time."–J. Graziano, Columbia U. Public Health
School.
There is no consensus among scientists. In 2004 the family of
Felicia Dunn-Jones, 42, who died from a rare lung disease was awarded $2.6
million from the Victim’s Compensation Fund.
Two years later, the New Jersey medical examiner blamed
toxins for the death of police officer James Zadroga, 34. "It is felt with a
reasonable degree of medical certainty that the cause of death in this case was
directly related to 9/11," stated the report from the medical examiner’s office
in Ocean County, N.J.
That "reasonable degree of medical certainty"–coroner
language for "as sure as I can be"–provides the first official link made by a
medical expert between the hazardous air at Ground Zero after the Trade Center
collapse and the death of someone who worked in the rescue effort.
The report of toxic mixture of dust and fumes reignited a fierce debate over
whether to classify deaths like that of Zadroga as being "in the line of duty,"
making survivors eligible for more benefits.