KANSAS CITY, Missouri—Food and fuel prices
are soaring and farmers are scrambling to meet demand. And for
makers of biotech crops, that adds up to a bright future.
Debate over the risk and benefits of such
crops, which use genes from other plants and other organisms to
effect special traits, still rages in many nations.
But from the US Midwest, where farmers this
spring will seed new fields full of transgenic soybeans and
corn, to the other side of the world where Chinese farmers are
growing genetically altered cotton and other crops, biotech
agriculture appears to be taking root.
"It’s my judgment that the ag biotech
industry has a huge head of steam," said Charles Benbrook,
former executive director of the Board on Agriculture of the
National Academy of Sciences and a critic of biotech crops.
"They are prevailing in wearing down the opposition."
The good times are rolling for US-based
Monsanto Co., a world leader in manipulating plant DNA to make
crops resistant to weedkillers and insect pests. The company’s
surging sales pushed its stock up 150 percent over the last year
as farmers stocked up on the company’s seeds and chemicals.
Corporate giants such as Syngenta, DuPont Co,
Bayer, BASF, and Dow Chemical Co are also expanding their reach
around the world, promoting technology they say can better help
feed people and livestock, create alternative fuels and put more
money in farmers’ hands.
Naysayers dispute that the tech giants are
doing anything more than deepening a base of chemical-friendly
crops that help boost sales of herbicides. The majority of the
biotech crops commercialized today are engineered to tolerate
dousings of herbicide to help farmers kill weeds easier.
But biotech backers say the proof is in the
bottom line. Acreage planted to the many different biotech crops
is expanding around the world as prices for food and fuel rise
rapidly and demand for corn, soybeans and other crops increases
in Asia, Latin America and other growing economies.
"It is being recognized that biotechnology is
important," said Paul Schickler, president of DuPont
agricultural unit Pioneer Hi-Bred International.
China is a key area of expansion. Both DuPont
and BASF have formed alliances there to accelerate transgenic
crop research in corn, beans and rice. China has already
embraced biotech cotton: an estimated 7 million Chinese farmers
planted seeds last year that are engineered to resist certain
insects.
Like many other nations, China has been slow
to embrace biotech crops as food. Indeed, the country has been a
key world supplier of non-GMO soy and corn. But biotech rice
varieties, with strains resistant to pests and diseases, are in
line for approval.
India, which likewise has seen rapid adoption
of biotech cotton, is also targeted for growth, though it still
has not embraced biotech crops for food.
Last month, South Korea did cross that line
by making its first purchase of genetically modified corn for
food. Premiums for conventional, non-GMO U.S. corn have trebled
from $10-$15 a ton a year ago and drove South Korea to the
switch.
Latin America is also seen as a growing
opportunity for biotech crop promoters. Brazil last month gave
clearance for two new varieties of GMO corn to be used for food,
and scientists are testing GMO sugar cane. Argentina, already a
big producer of biotech soybeans, recently approved a new GMO
corn.
Still, there are many who believe biotech
crops do more to fatten corporate earnings and investor bank
accounts than help farmers or the environment. They cite
increased use of chemicals, creation of "superweeds" and
potential health problems among the concerns.
The environmental group Friends of the Earth
said last month that use of biotech crops engineered to tolerate
Monsanto’s Roundup herbicide has led to large increases in
herbicide use, which in turn has spawned an epidemic of
herbicide-resistant weeds in the United States, Argentina and
Brazil.
Scientists have reported glyphosate-resistant
weeds infesting 2.4 million acres in the United States alone,
making farmers use more and different chemicals to kill the "superweeds,"
according to the group.
Opponents also warn that farmers are being
trapped into a cycle of dependence on the corporate giants who
patent the biotech seeds they develop. Traditionally farmers
saved seed from harvested crops. But if they plant a biotech
variety, they must buy new seed every season at ever higher
prices.
There are also concerns that biotech food may do long-term
damage to human health. Biotech crop critics say GM foods have
the potential to contribute to a range of health problems.
– Reuters