Deutsche Bank said the rice crisis is passing
and warned the government against panicky reaction like sharp
adjustment in wages, which, it said, would only drive up
inflation.
"At the end of the day, the rice crisis is a
shock whose effects, like that of bird-flu in 2001, may become a
distant memory a year later," Anton Periquet, strategist of
Deutsche Bank, said in the bank’s April 30 review on the
country’s rice situation.
"The real danger lies in how the government
responds – if politicians press the panic button and responds to
the temporary shock with measures that permanently increase
costs – i.e., legislated wage increases that outstrip
productivity growth – they run the risk of triggering a supply
chain reaction that will be almost impossible to reverse," he
said.
Runaway inflation, more than the subprime
crisis, is a "serious threat to the Philippines, not just
"raising business costs" but reducing the "real value of
household budgets in an economy with a low savings buffer," he
said.
"The effect on discretionary spending will be
immediate, with negative implications on company earnings," the
analyst said.
In a conference call the German bank
conducted last week, Periquet said panelists were in a consensus
that while there is a "clear supply-demand imbalance," "the
crisis would pass."
"But at the same time, there was also a
suspicion that the spike in world prices this year is in part
being fueled by the Philippine government’s aggressive (and
pre-announced) buying into a thin market, at a time when key
suppliers Thailand and Vietnam were cutting exports," Periquet
said.
Deutsche Bank noted that the Philippines is
the world’s largest rice importer, and hence its pronouncements
on supply shortages can send shocks to the market.
University of the Philippines Prof. Benjamin
Diokno, a former budget secretary and one of the panelists at
the conference call, pointed out that market forces would
correct over time.
Diokno said at current prices, farmers were
already planting more rice. Rice takes about 5-6 months to grow
and is harvested twice a year. So, he said, in the absence of
supply bottlenecks, shortages needn’t last for extended periods.
Periquet said the consensus was that "prices
would at least halve before the end of the year."
He said, citing the observation of the
panelists, the high rice prices have benefited the country’s
rice-planting families, which constitute about 12 percent or 11
million of the country’s 90 million population.
"The consensus, though, was that the net
effect on the economy would be negative, as practically
everybody, including the rice farmer, is a rice consumer."
Diokno said as a result of the price
increases, average inflation is likely to settle at six percent
this year, topping the official target of 3-5 percent.
Consequently, as a result of consumer
spending slowing from the erosion of their purchasing power, he
said domestic growth is likely to come in at five percent, less
bullish than the official target of 6.3-7 percent.