Fitch keeps
ratings at stable,
but warns of downgrade
BY JIMMY C. CALAPATI
London-based Fitch Ratings yesterday said it
is maintaining its stable outlook for the country, but warned of
a possible downgrade.
Fitch affirmed the national government’s
long-term foreign and local currency issuer default ratings (IDRs)
at "BB" and "BB+," respectively.
The agency also affirmed the short-term IDR
at "B" and the country ceiling at "BB+."
The outlook on the ratings is stable.
But the credit rating agency warned of a
possible negative rating if the government does not manage its
expenses and raise the necessary revenues.
James McCormack, head of Asia sovereigns at
Fitch said that "while the Philippines has not been directly
exposed to some of the most serious aspects of the international
financial crisis, including, for example, severe stresses
affecting the domestic banking system, it is not impervious to
the deterioration in global economic growth prospects."
Fitch, thus, further cut its growth forecast
to 0.1 percent, from the April forecast of 0.5 percent, due to
the slowdown in consumer spending and overseas remittances as
well as the contraction in exports.
"Based on a sharp reduction in exports, which
is expected to be only partially offset by weaker imports, and a
forecast 6.8 percent decline in remittances, the agency
forecasts lower Philippine GDP growth in 2009," McCormack said.
The new forecast is below the downscaled
forecast range of 3.1 to 4.1 percent by the Development Budget
Coordinating Committee.
Fitch forecasts a fiscal deficit of P271
billion, excluding P5 billion in privatization receipts,
equivalent to 3.5 percent of GDP.
"The fall in tax revenue in the first quarter
will be very difficult to make up in the remainder of the year
as the economy slows," McCormack said.
Government revenue was down by 4 percent in
the first quarter, marking the weakest Q1 revenue outturn in 22
years.
Fitch assumes there will be further fiscal
policy adjustments as the year progresses, and the agency
expects spending to be slightly below the current target by
year-end.
"Consequently, if forecast increases in
spending are not reversed once the economy begins to recover, or
revenue collection is not stepped up considerably, there is a
risk that Philippine government debt ratios may deviate further
from the ‘BB’ medians, with possible negative rating
implications," McCormack said.
The forecast increase in the Philippine
fiscal deficit in 2009 is in line with those of other "BB"-rated
sovereigns, as is the deficit level itself.
"In terms of government debt, however, the
Philippines compares unfavorably with its rating peers,"
McCormack said.
In 2008, the Philippine national government
debt/GDP ratio was 56.3 percent, compared to the "BB"
consolidated general government debt median of 30.6 percent.
The debt/revenue ratio is even more telling,
with the Philippines at 360 percent versus the peer median of
141 percent.
Fitch has long considered the Philippines’
low government revenue base—among the lowest of all rated
sovereigns—to be a fundamental rating weakness.
With a much weaker economy and elections due
next year, the agency does not believe revenue enhancement will
be a short-term policy priority.
Fitch expects remittances to continue to fall
gradually in 2009.
Overseas remittances were $16.4 billion in
2008 (10 percent of GDP), providing critical support to economic
growth by supplementing household income.
Remittance inflows also more than offset the
$12.6 billion trade deficit, resulting in a $4.2 billion current
account surplus.
Remittances were still growing year-on-year
in February 2009, but they peaked in June 2008 and have been
trending lower, consistent with the state of the global economy.
Taking changes in remittances and the trade
balance into account, Fitch forecasts a halving of the current
account surplus this year to $2.1 billion.
"Combining the current account balance and
external amortization payments, the Philippine gross external
financing requirement for 2009 is forecast at $2.8 billion,
equivalent to 7.3 percent of end-2008 foreign exchange
reserves," McCormack said.
The "BB" median is 51 percent, confirming the
comparative external sector strength of the Philippines, even
with much weaker exports and a moderate fall in remittances.