Open skies
Airlines debate pluses, minuses
By GENIVI FACTAO
The members of the Association of South East
Asian Nations have agreed that unlimited flights between capital
cities in the region will begin next month.
Asean leaders also target a single Asean
aviation market by 2015.
The country’s airline executives see many
advantages in the plan. The country’s flag carrier, the
Philippine Airlines has been very vocal against opening up
Philippine skies without demanding reciprocal rights.
"Any policy that opens up the Philippines to
foreign airlines while restricting the growth of RP airlines is
shortsighted", said Rolando G. Estabillo, vice president,
corporate communications department.
Estabillo also pointed out that local
airlines will be competing with other airlines that are
government owned and subsidized.
Avelino L. Zapanta, president of South East
Asian Airlines and former president of PAL, said that open skies
will work for smaller airlines which can serve limited markets.
All the local airlines are bracing themselves
to compete once the passenger and cargo services in the region
are fully liberalized.
PAL said Asean open skies will open up
opportunities for expansion in various markets.
Estabillo said that PAL has already expanded
flights to Singapore, Bangkok, Jakarta, and may consider further
expansion upon delivery of brand new Airbus A320 aircraft.
"Other ASEAN countries are not being required
to privatize their major airlines and relinquish government
control, subsidy and protection of these state-owned carriers ——
thus retaining their unfair advantages in competing with
legitimate business enterprises like PAL," he said.
"We are competing with no government
subsidies or bailouts. Instead, we have to rely on our own
dynamism, agility in marketplace competition, enhancement of
services, and moves to develop new strategic markets," Estabillo
said.
PAL, stressed that any policy that opens up
the Philippines to foreign airlines while restricting the growth
of RP airlines is shortsighted.
PAL cited the EO 500 series of policies that
allow unlimited flights by foreign airlines to Clark and Subic,
without requiring that RP airlines be given equal opportunity to
fly unlimited flights in the same manner.
"Happily, RP government has been negotiating
a series of new air agreements in recent months, with Malaysia,
Thailand, Hong Kong, Canada, Iran, Finland, New Zealand, Macau,
Cambodia, etc., that allow reciprocal access for both RP and
foreign airlines to Philippine airports, especially Clark. When
all parties work together in partnership, the national interest
is served well," Estabillo claimed.
Zapanta explained that big players with big
aircraft will not fly to some of the opened routes. "Small
players can penetrate the routes that have been opened more
easily than the big ones. For example, the first stage where
only 3rd & 4th freedom are liberated and to capital cities only.
How many big ASEAN players are flying to ASEAN capital cities
like Hanoi, Phnom Penh, Vientiane, Naypyidaw, and Bandar Seri
Begawan? None or one or two. Why? The big players with big
aircraft will not fly to small destinations. So why don’t the
small players fly there? It’s either they are not designated or
the routes are not open. Now with ASEAN open skies, the small
players can start small in small routes with smaller aircraft,
something the big ones won’t do," he explained.
Zapanta said the ASEAN open skies will lead
to the introduction of new air sectors to be opened by the
smaller operators who are enabled by open designation that the
treaty espouses. This should lead to expanded commercial
aviation operation within the region.
Passengers and shippers see the open skies
policy would help bring down the cost due to competition.
PAL readily accepts the challenges not only
in growing in the ASEAN but North Asia and North America
markets, as well.
PAL is said to be the biggest RP airline
serving the ASEAN market with flights operating 56 times a week
to ASEAN destinations.
PAL offers more flights per week on each of
the contested ASEAN routes:
PAL flies 7 times weekly to Jakarta, 14 times
weekly to Bangkok, 28 times weekly to Singapore, and 7 times a
week to Ho Chi Minh City (Saigon).
Zapanta on the other hand, explained that it
is high time that the RP Civil Aeronautics Board (CAB) allow
more entrants into the industry because the other countries will
do the same.
"If we limit the opportunity to PAL and Cebu
Pacific no RP carrier will help pioneer the small routes..,"
Zapanta said.
The open skies policy, will definitely
benefit our overseas Filipino workers.
"It is time the government think whether
protecting the airlines is good for the country and its economy
for after all, the RP airlines’ total revenue is only a small
fraction of the total remittances of OFWs. The airlines generate
no more than $5 billion in a year. The OFWs remit about $15
billion a year. They deserve all the help we can give them,"
Zapanta ended.