n 2005, the late director gen-eral of
the World Health Or-ganization, Dr. Lee Jun-Wok, set up the Commission on the
Social Determinants of Health. Its job was to marshal evidence on what could be
done to promote health equity.
Last month, after working for three years, the Commission
issued its final report titled "Closing the Gap in a Generation – Health Equity
through Action on the Social Determinants of Health."
Chaired by a well-respected epidemiologist, Prof. Michael
Marmot of the United Kingdom, the Commission’s members were a diverse group
ranging from a former president of Chile to health ministers and health experts
to a Nobel laureate in economics. But despite their different backgrounds, the
chairman noted that "everyone connected to the Commission was united in three
concerns: a passion for social justice, a respect for evidence, and a
frustration that there appeared to be far too little action on the social
determinants of health."
"Closing the Gap" did not reveal any startlingly new findings
about the relationships between social status and health. However, its
methodical exposition of the evidence on these relationships and how widespread
they were across the globe provides documentation that should initiate action by
responsible authorities not only in the health sector but at all levels and
areas.
For the Philippines, the findings of the Commission
underscored the fact that, as repeatedly asserted in past forums, our country
situation mirrors the global situation in almost all aspects especially in the
disgraceful health inequities between the rich minority and the poor majority of
Filipinos.
The recommendations on the approaches to reducing health
inequities are also very much applicable to our situation. These approaches are
based on an all-encompassing concern for social justice which, the report
asserts, "is a matter of life and death. It affects the way people live, their
consequent chance of illness, and their risk of premature death."
The Commission proposes three overarching recommendations for
dealing with inequities in health. It is obvious from these that reforming the
health sector to deal with inequality cannot be the business of the health
sector alone because not all the factors that promote inequity are within its
sphere.
The first of these is to improve living conditions for all
because "the inequities in how society is organized mean that the freedom to
lead a flourishing life and to enjoy good health is unequally distributed
between and within societies. This inequity is seen in the conditions of early
childhood and schooling, the nature of employment and working conditions, the
physical form of the built environment, and the quality of the natural
environment."
The second overarching recommendation is to tackle the
inequitable distribution of power, money, and resources because "inequity in the
conditions of daily living is shaped by deeper social structures and processes.
The inequity is systemic, produced by social norms, policies, and practices that
tolerate or actually promote unfair distribution of and access to power, wealth,
and other necessary social resources."
The third recommendation is to measure and understand the
problem and to assess the impact of action because "the world is changing fast
and often it is unclear the impact that social, economic, and political change
will have on health in general and on health inequities in particular. Action on
the social determinants of health will be more effective if basic data systems,
including vital registration and routine monitoring of health inequity and the
social determinants of health are in place."
"Closing the Gap in a Generation" is a very important
document that will help to understand the underpinnings of health inequity. It
should be required reading for individuals who have any interest in trying to
remedy the problem of inequity in the Philippine health system. The document
provides materials to support the argument that it is time to elevate the level
of politicization of health from that of parochial self-interests and petty
patronage to a national issue of common concern.
Unfortunately, despite the fact that polls show that health
is a priority issue for most Filipinos, politicians’ have for the most part
shown a rather shallow appreciation of the issues. It is for this reason that
political campaigns for any post always feature medical missions and
distributions of medicines (mostly unnecessary). The most common promise of
politicians to their constituents is to build yet another hospital or health
center or health station.
Hopefully, the publication of "Closing the Gap in a
Generation" coupled with the promotion of the attainment of the millennium
development goals will encourage deeper thinking about the situation of health
in the Philippines. Perhaps a true concern for the health of poor Filipinos will
also convince some of the more conservative religious groups to reconsider their
stance on reproductive health, information and services which will empower poor
couples to become responsible couples, allow them to pay more attention to their
family needs, and avoid the many health risks associated with reproductive
ignorance.
***
The initial confusion and delays in the response of Philippine health
authorities to the melamine contaminated food products from China reflects the
inherent weaknesses of the food and drug regulatory system now in place. It
turns out that this problem came at a very awkward time for the Bureau of Food
and Drugs. Its deputy director, who was effectively the agency’s main
trouble-shooter, had just resigned. There had just been a reshuffle of division
chiefs that had caused a level of demoralization because it had been done to
appease a powerful multinational food company at the behest of the Department of
Trade and Industry. Hopefully, after things settle back to normal following this
melamine affair, the story behind the turmoil of the country’s food and drug
safety agency can be told as one of the basis for reforms of food and drug
regulations expected with the passage of a pending BFAD strengthening law.